Controversy over student loan forgiveness. 

Source: https://www.foxbusiness.com/personal-finance/think-tanks-file-suit-block-biden-administrations-plan-cancel-39b-student-loans
Source: https://www.foxbusiness.com/personal-finance/think-tanks-file-suit-block-biden-administrations-plan-cancel-39b-student-loans

Helium Summary: The Biden Administration's plan to cancel $39 billion in student loans is facing a legal challenge from the Mackinac Center for Public Policy and the Cato Institute.

Critics argue this plan exceeds the administration's authority [Fox Business].

The decision follows a past Supreme Court ruling against a larger student loan forgiveness plan [timeshighereducation.com (Opinion)].

Meanwhile, the freeze on repayments, initiated due to COVID-19, is lifting [Forbes], leading to financial worries for many, including those facing their first repayments, like Gen Z [Forbes].


August 11, 2023


Perspectives

Pro-Biden Relief Plan


Biden's cancellation plan aims to alleviate strain on borrowers, particularly those in low-income brackets, making repayments adjustable [Alternet]

Against Biden Relief Plan


Critics argue the plan solely serves borrowers and ignores tax expenses from other population sectors uninvolved in loan contracts [time.com]

Educational Bias


Observations suggest systemic issues with increasing tuition fees and dependence on governmental loan programs as a primary source of revenue for colleges [timeshighereducation.com (Opinion)].


Relevant Trades

[SLM] SLM


Q&A


Who filed the lawsuit against the Biden administration's student loan forgiveness plan?

The Cato Institute and Mackinac Center for Public Policy filed the lawsuit [Fox Business].

What's the primary concern on lifting the repayment freeze?

Many borrowers, especially the young or unemployed, are worried about making repayments in the wake of Covid-19, particularly those dealing with repayments for the first time [Daily Kos][Forbes].


News Media Bias (?)


The listed sources display a slight leaning towards pro-loan forgiveness, often portraying the borrowers' difficulties in returning to repayment.

However, they do represent perspectives of critics [timeshighereducation.com (Opinion)][time.com].


Context


This issue is within the broader context of student loan debt crisis, a mix of systemic educational issues and the consequences of a pandemic.


Takeaway


Biden's plan, aimed at lessening borrower burden, faces opposition arguing overreach. As legal battles ensue, repayment freeze lifts, causing borrower anxiety.


Potential Outcomes



1. Biden's plan gets blocked, leading to no cancellations.

2. The plan proceeds, cancelling $39 billion in loans.

3. The number of delinquencies increase after repayment freeze lifts.



Similar Stories



Supreme Court justices' controversial decisions

Supreme Court justices face criticism and controversy amidst decisions that cross ideological lines.

June 28, 2023
Supreme Court kills student loan forgiveness

Supreme Court rules Biden administration can't cancel student debt; Payments resume in October.

July 04, 2023
Biden plans student loan forgiveness.

Biden's $39 billion student loan forgiveness plan was announced, benefitting over 800,000 borrowers.

July 31, 2023




Deepen Your Understanding of The World      





Read Deeper on: Controversy over student loan forgiveness.

    

Biden's Student Loan Forgiveness Was Always a Sham | Opinion - Newsweek

The Supreme Court has dealt the coup de grace to the Biden Administration's student loan forgiveness program. Consistent with the Court's emphasis on the Constitution's separation of powers, the Court ruled that Congress had not granted Biden the legal authority to forgive debt amounting to perhaps $980 billion over 10 years. The Administration has repeatedly tried to short-circuit the legislative process by issuing major policy initiatives with scarcely a nod to Congress. The Roberts Court has rightly stymied its unconstitutional power grab again.

Newsweek (Opinion)     Jun 30, 2023


How did each Supreme Court justice vote in today's student loan forgiveness ruling? Here's a breakdown - CBS News

How did each Supreme Court justice vote in today's student loan forgiveness ruling? Here's a breakdown News

CBS     Jun 30, 2023


Sweeping student loan forgiveness not allowed, Supreme Court rules - Medical Economics

Sweeping student loan forgiveness not allowed, Supreme Court rulesMedical Economics

medicaleconomics.com     Jun 30, 2023


Amy Coney Barrett uses bizarre analogy of babysitter and amusement park in student loan opinion

Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett was one of the conservative justices who struck down Biden's loan forgiveness plan, but her explanation as to why included talk of babysitters and amusement parks left some people scratching their heads in confusion.Barrett used the opinion, which ruled that the Biden administration didn't have the authority to authorize the forgiveness, to push for the "major questions doctrine," according to CNN."The so-called major questions doctrine says that executive branch agencies only have authority to take aggressive unilateral action of significant political or economic importance if Congress explicitly gives it such power," the news network reported.

Alternet (Opinion)     Jun 30, 2023


Why Justice Amy Coney Barrett wrote about babysitters in her student loan opinion - CNN

Justice Amy Coney Barrett, in a concurrence to Friday’s ruling striking down President Joe Biden’s student debt forgiveness plan, defended the Supreme Court conservative majority’s use of a controversial legal theory and – deploying analogies concerning babysitters and grocery store owners – laid out how she believed the doctrine should be used in the future.

CNN (Opinion)     Jun 30, 2023


Editorial | Ruling on Biden's student-loan plan a foregone conclusion - News-Gazette

President Joe Biden was sorely disappointed last week when the U.S. Supreme Court struck down his unilateral decision to forgive student-loan debt at a cost of as much as $519 billion to taxpayers.

news-gazette.com (Opinion)     Jul 07, 2023


Student loan repayment: Nearly half of Americans with college debt to cut essential spending

Student loan repayment: Nearly half of Americans with college debt to cut essential spending

With student loan payments underway after the federal pause ended, many Americans are cutting back on essentials to make ends meet, MassMutual found. But Biden’s student loan relief initiatives aim to help borrowers now.

Fox Business     Oct 05, 2023


The Supreme Court is out of control and must be reformed

The Supreme Court wrapped up this term with a pair of completely arbitrary and capricious rulings, based on lies and controversies manufactured by far-right political actors, restricting LGBTQ protections and striking down President Joe Biden’s student loan forgiveness program. Both cases were deeply flawed procedurally, but that wasn’t going to stop the six far-right extremists on the court from imposing their will. This illegitimate court has once again wreaked untold future damage on this country. It has to be stopped. In 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis, the court took on a case conjured up by the far-right Christian group Alliance Defending Freedom based on a lie, and then, in the words of Justice Sonia Sotomayor in her ...

Daily Kos     Jun 30, 2023


Older people also face student loan debt burden with payments ... - Marketplace

Student loan interest charges kick in this month after a hiatus of more than three years in response to the pandemic. And loan payments will restart next month, in October. Among the people who borrowed to pay for their college education is a group largely overlooked in policy debates: student loan borrowers who still are paying back at age 60 and older.

marketplace.org     Sep 14, 2023


Student-loan borrowers are less than 24 hours away from finding out if they'll get Biden's debt cancellation

The wait is over. The Supreme Court will decide whether Biden's student-debt cancellation plan is legal on Friday, the last day of the court's term.

Business Insider     Jun 29, 2023


What Supreme Court rejection of student loan relief means

Supreme Court rejection of student loan relief could narrow presidential power, and provide a hot issue for 2024.

Christian Science Monitor     Jun 30, 2023


Blockbuster Supreme Court decisions to come on student loans, affirmative action and more - ABC News

The Supreme Court has left this term's blockbuster decisions for last, with rulings expected this week on student loans, affirmative action and more.

ABC (Opinion)     Jun 26, 2023


Unforgiven: The Supreme Court and the Student Loan Conundrum

Its rejection of the Biden administration’s plan fuels cynicism and seems to foreclose similar initiatives going forward. The post

Washington Monthly     Jul 07, 2023


Supreme Court Bingo, 2023 Edition

politics

As we approach the end of the Supreme Court's 2022 term, major cases involving affirmative action, the constitutionality of President Biden's student loan forgiveness program, and the ability of individuals to refuse to provide services for same sex weddings on the basis of their religious beliefs are still outstanding. This is consistent with the Supreme Court's basic approach, where the most controversial cases aren't released until the end of the term.

Real Clear Politics     Jun 27, 2023


Why Dave Ramsey Advises Against Student Loan Income-Driven Repayment Plans - Yahoo Finance

Personal finance pros often hail income-driven repayment (IDR) plans as an excellent option for dealing with student loan debt. One particularly well-known expert isn’t convinced, though.

Yahoo     Aug 08, 2023


AOC Had Student Debt While Calling for Student Debt Cancellation

In a bizarre attempt at a gotcha, Fox News notes that the New York Congresswoman held student debt while calling for debt cancellation. But AOC has been open about holding debt. AOC’s Latest So-Called Controversy One of the parts of Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY)’s appeal,when she first entered politics, was that she wasmore of a […] The post

1945     Aug 18, 2023